What Did the Franck-Hertz Experiment Reveal About Atoms?

The Franck-Hertz experiment of 1914 demonstrated that atoms absorb internal excitation energy from colliding electrons only in discrete, quantized amounts rather than continuously. By measuring periodic drops in electrical current as electrons were accelerated through low-pressure mercury vapor, James Franck and Gustav Hertz provided the first direct non-spectroscopic confirmation of Niels Bohr's quantized atomic energy levels and showed that the kinetic energy lost in inelastic electron-atom collisions exactly matches the energy of ultraviolet photons emitted by the excited atoms.

Experimental Design and Measurement Procedure

James Franck and Gustav Hertz constructed a vacuum tube containing low-pressure mercury \((\text{Hg})\) vapor equipped with three electrodes:

  1. A heated filament cathode \(C\) that emitted thermal electrons.
  2. A perforated wire mesh accelerating grid \(G\) placed a few millimeters from the cathode and held at an adjustable positive voltage \(V\) relative to \(C\).
  3. A collector plate (anode) \(A\) placed just behind the grid and maintained at a small negative retarding potential \(V_r \approx 0.5\text{ V}\) to \(1.5\text{ V}\) relative to the grid.

Electrons emitted by the cathode were accelerated toward the grid by the potential \(V\), acquiring kinetic energy \(K = eV\). Only electrons arriving at the grid with kinetic energy exceeding the small retarding barrier \(eV_r\) could reach the collector plate and register as an anode current \(I\) on a sensitive ammeter.

Elastic Versus Inelastic Collisions in Mercury Vapor

In classical physics, collisions between accelerated electrons and massive mercury atoms should transfer energy continuously over a broad range depending on the impact parameter. Instead, as Franck and Hertz gradually increased the accelerating voltage \(V\) from zero, they observed a striking periodic pattern in the collector current \(I\):

  • Below \(4.9\text{ V}\): As \(V\) increased from \(0\text{ V}\) to \(4.9\text{ V}\), the collector current \(I\) rose steadily. Because a mercury atom is roughly \(3.7 \times 10^5\) times more massive than an electron, collisions in this regime were purely elastic; electrons bounced off mercury atoms with negligible kinetic energy loss and easily overcame the retarding potential \(V_r\) to reach the collector.
  • Sharp Drop at \(4.9\text{ V}\): When the accelerating voltage reached \(V_1 = 4.9\text{ V}\), the collector current dropped abruptly almost to zero. At this threshold, electrons just in front of the grid reached a kinetic energy of \(K = 4.9\text{ eV}\) and underwent inelastic collisions with mercury atoms, transferring virtually all \(4.9\text{ eV}\) of their kinetic energy into the internal excitation of a mercury atom from its ground state \(E_0\) to its first excited state \(E_1\):

\[\Delta E = E_1 - E_0 = eV_1 = 4.9\text{ eV}\]

Having lost their kinetic energy, these electrons could no longer surmount the small retarding potential \(V_r\) to reach the anode.

  • Periodic Maxima at Multiples of \(4.9\text{ V}\): As the voltage was increased further, the current rose again until \(V = 9.8\text{ V}\), where it dropped sharply a second time, followed by a third drop at \(V = 14.7\text{ V}\). At \(V = n \times 4.9\text{ V}\) (for integer \(n = 1, 2, 3, \dots\)), an electron underwent \(n\) successive inelastic collisions along its path from cathode to grid, losing \(4.9\text{ eV}\) each time.

Spectroscopic Verification of Bohr's Frequency Condition

Crucially, Franck and Hertz also monitored the ultraviolet radiation emitted by the mercury vapor tube using a quartz spectrograph. When the accelerating voltage remained below \(4.9\text{ V}\), no radiation was emitted. As soon as the voltage exceeded \(4.9\text{ V}\), the mercury vapor emitted a single sharp ultraviolet spectral line at a wavelength of \(\lambda = 253.7\text{ nm}\).

According to Niels Bohr's frequency relation \(\Delta E = h\nu = hc/\lambda\), the photon energy corresponding to \(\lambda = 253.7\text{ nm}\) is:

\[\Delta E = \frac{hc}{\lambda} = \frac{(4.136 \times 10^{-15}\text{ eV}\cdot\text{s})(2.998 \times 10^8\text{ m/s})}{253.7 \times 10^{-9}\text{ m}} \approx 4.89\text{ eV}\]

This direct correspondence between the mechanical kinetic energy lost by colliding electrons (\(4.9\text{ eV}\)) and the optical photon energy emitted during atomic de-excitation (\(4.89\text{ eV}\)) proved conclusively that atoms possess discrete internal energy states, validating a central pillar of quantum mechanics.