How Did the Davisson-Germer Experiment Prove Matter Waves?
The Davisson-Germer electron diffraction experiment validated wave-particle duality in 1927 by demonstrating that a beam of low-energy electrons scattered from the surface of a single nickel crystal forms sharp constructive interference peaks identical to X-ray Bragg diffraction. By showing that the angular positions of these diffraction maxima quantitatively matched the wavelength \(\lambda = h/p\) predicted by Louis de Broglie, Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer provided the first direct experimental proof that material particles exhibit wave behavior.
Background: Testing de Broglie's Matter Wave Hypothesis
In 1924, Louis de Broglie proposed that every material particle with momentum \(p\) has an associated matter wave of wavelength \(\lambda = h/p\). For an electron of mass \(m_e\) and charge \(e\) accelerated from rest through an electrostatic potential difference \(V\), its non-relativistic kinetic energy is \(K = eV = \frac{p^2}{2m_e}\), which yields a theoretical de Broglie wavelength of:
\[\lambda = \frac{h}{p} = \frac{h}{\sqrt{2 m_e e V}}\]
For accelerating voltages on the order of \(10\text{ V}\) to \(100\text{ V}\), this wavelength is approximately \(0.1\text{ nm}\) to \(0.4\text{ nm}\), comparable to the interatomic lattice spacing of crystalline solids. Just as Max von Laue and William Lawrence Bragg had used crystals as three-dimensional diffraction gratings to establish the wave nature of X-rays, Walter Elsasser suggested that crystalline solids could diffract electron beams if de Broglie's hypothesis was correct.
Experimental Apparatus and Discovery of Nickel Diffraction
At Bell Telephone Laboratories, Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer directed a monoenergetic beam of electrons from an electron gun onto the polished face of a nickel target inside an ultrahigh-vacuum chamber. A movable Faraday cup detector mounted on an arc measured the intensity of elastically scattered electrons as a function of the scattering angle \(\theta\) and the accelerating voltage \(V\).
Initially, their polycrystalline nickel target produced only smooth angular scattering distributions. However, after a vacuum accident oxidized the target, Davisson and Germer annealed the nickel at high temperature in hydrogen. This heating recrystallized the polycrystalline sample into a few large single crystals with well-ordered atomic planes parallel to the surface. When they resumed scattering measurements on the single-crystal nickel target, strong, sharp peaks in scattered electron intensity appeared at specific combinations of voltage and angle.
Quantitative Confirmation of Bragg's Law and de Broglie's Formula
The sharpest diffraction maximum occurred at an accelerating voltage of \(V = 54\text{ V}\) and a scattering co-latitude angle of \(\theta = 50^{\circ}\) between the incident and scattered beams. From X-ray crystallography, the spacing \(D\) between adjacent rows of atoms on the surface of the nickel crystal (related to the bulk interplanar spacing \(d\) by \(d = D\sin(\theta/2)\)) was known to be \(D = 0.215\text{ nm}\).
Treating the surface atomic rows as a reflection diffraction grating, constructive interference between electron waves scattered from adjacent atomic rows requires the path difference to equal an integer multiple \(n\) of the wavelength \(\lambda\):
\[n\lambda = D\sin\theta\]
For the first-order peak (\(n = 1\)) at \(\theta = 50^{\circ}\) with \(D = 0.215\text{ nm}\), the experimentally measured wavelength was:
\[\lambda_{\text{exp}} = (0.215\text{ nm}) \sin(50^{\circ}) \approx 0.165\text{ nm}\]
Evaluating de Broglie's theoretical formula at \(V = 54\text{ V}\) yields:
\[\lambda_{\text{theory}} = \frac{h}{\sqrt{2 m_e e (54\text{ V})}} \approx \frac{1.226\text{ nm}\cdot\text{V}^{1/2}}{\sqrt{54\text{ V}}} \approx 0.167\text{ nm}\]
The close agreement between \(\lambda_{\text{exp}} = 0.165\text{ nm}\) and \(\lambda_{\text{theory}} = 0.167\text{ nm}\) (with the small residual difference explained by the inner electrostatic potential refractive index of the nickel crystal) decisively confirmed de Broglie's wavelength-momentum relation.
Impact on Quantum Mechanics
Alongside George Paget Thomson's independent thin-film electron diffraction experiments in Scotland, the Davisson-Germer experiment established that electrons--discovered as discrete corpuscles by J. J. Thomson thirty years earlier--propagate and interfere as coherent waves. This experimental validation cemented wave-particle duality as a universal principle of nature and confirmed the physical reality of the wave function in Schrodinger's wave mechanics.