Why Linear Momentum is Conserved in Isolated Collisions

This article provides a direct explanation of why linear momentum remains constant during a collision within an isolated physics system. By examining the definitions of momentum and isolated systems, the mechanics of impulse, and the direct application of Newton’s Second and Third Laws of Motion, this guide demonstrates how internal forces cancel out to keep total momentum unchanged before and after an impact.

Defining Momentum and Isolated Systems

To understand conservation, we must first define the two core concepts involved:

  • Linear Momentum (\(p\)): This is the measure of an object's motion, calculated by multiplying its mass (\(m\)) by its velocity (\(v\)), resulting in the formula \(p = mv\). Because velocity is a vector (it has both magnitude and direction), momentum is also a vector.
  • Isolated System: An isolated system is a collection of objects that does not interact with its surroundings. This means the net external force acting on the system is zero. There is no friction, air resistance, or external pushing and pulling influencing the objects involved.

Newton’s Second Law and External Forces

Newton’s Second Law of Motion is often written as \(F = ma\) (Force equals mass times acceleration), but Newton originally formulated it in terms of momentum: the net force acting on a system is equal to the rate of change of its momentum (\(\Sigma F = \Delta p / \Delta t\)).

In an isolated system, the net external force (\(\Sigma F\)) is zero. According to the equation, if the net force is zero, the change in momentum (\(\Delta p\)) must also be zero. Therefore, no outside influence can add to or subtract from the system's total momentum.

Newton’s Third Law and Internal Forces

While there are no external forces in an isolated system, a collision involves massive internal forces as the objects crash into one another. The reason these internal forces do not change the total momentum of the system comes down to Newton’s Third Law of Motion, which states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.

Imagine Object A and Object B colliding. During the impact:

  • Object A exerts a force on Object B (\(F_{AB}\)).
  • Simultaneously, Object B exerts a force on Object A (\(F_{BA}\)).

According to Newton's Third Law, these two forces are exactly equal in magnitude and opposite in direction: \(F_{AB} = -F_{BA}\)

Impulse: How the Changes Cancel Out

A change in momentum is called an impulse, which is calculated by multiplying the force acting on an object by the time duration the force is applied (\(Impulse = F \times \Delta t\)).

During a collision between Object A and Object B, the duration of the impact (\(\Delta t\)) is goes on for the exact same amount of time for both objects. You cannot have Object A touching Object B for a longer time than Object B touches Object A.

Because the contact time (\(\Delta t\)) is identical for both objects, and the forces are equal and opposite (\(F_{AB} = -F_{BA}\)), the impulses experienced by both objects are also equal and opposite: \(F_{AB} \times \Delta t = -F_{BA} \times \Delta t\)

This means the change in momentum for Object A is the exact negative of the change in momentum for Object B: \(\Delta p_A = -\Delta p_B\)

The Final Result

When you add the momentum changes of both objects together to find the total change in the system's momentum, they cancel each other out completely: \(\Delta p_A + \Delta p_B = 0\)

If Object A loses a specific amount of momentum during the crash, Object B gains that exact same amount. Momentum is simply transferred from one object to the other. Because no momentum can enter or leave the isolated system, and the internal forces cancel each other out during the interaction, the total linear momentum before the collision is always equal to the total linear momentum after the collision.