Open Sets in the Axiomatic Formulation of Topology

This article provides a concise overview of how open sets are defined within the axiomatic framework of point-set topology. Rather than relying on geometric measurements like distance, point-set topology defines open sets abstractly as members of a specific collection of subsets known as a topology. This article breaks down the three fundamental axioms that govern this collection—the inclusion of the whole space and empty set, closure under arbitrary unions, and closure under finite intersections—and explains how these rules generalize mathematical concepts like continuity and closeness.

In introductory mathematics, open sets are often taught using the concept of distance. For example, on the real number line, an open interval is a set where every point has some distance between itself and the boundary of the set. However, in the axiomatic formulation of point-set topology, the concept of distance is stripped away.

Instead of defining what makes an individual set "open" based on its internal properties, we start with a foundational set \(X\) and choose a collection of its subsets, denoted as \(\tau\) (tau). We simply declare that the subsets inside the collection \(\tau\) are the "open sets."

However, we cannot just pick any random collection of subsets. For \(\tau\) to be a valid topology—and therefore for its members to be legitimately called open sets—the collection \(\tau\) must satisfy three strict axioms.

The Three Axioms of Open Sets

Given a set \(X\), a topology \(\tau\) is a collection of subsets of \(X\) that obeys the following three rules. A subset of \(X\) is defined as an open set if and only if it is an element of \(\tau\).

  1. The Empty Set and the Whole Space are Open: Both the empty set (\(\emptyset\)) and the entire set \(X\) must be included in the collection \(\tau\).

  2. Closure Under Arbitrary Unions: The union of any collection of open sets must also be an open set. This applies to both a finite number of open sets and an infinite (even uncountably infinite) number of open sets. If you combine any number of sets from \(\tau\), the resulting set must also be in \(\tau\).

  3. Closure Under Finite Intersections: The intersection of any finite number of open sets must also be an open set. If you take a finite list of sets from \(\tau\), the region where they all overlap must also be in \(\tau\).

What This Means in Practice

In this axiomatic system, "openness" is not an intrinsic property of a set; it is a status granted by the specific topology \(\tau\) you are working with. The exact same subset of \(X\) might be an open set in one topology, and not an open set in another.

Here are three classic examples of how different choices of \(\tau\) define open sets on the same underlying set \(X\):

  • The Indiscrete (Trivial) Topology: The collection \(\tau\) contains only \(\emptyset\) and \(X\). This is the smallest possible topology. Here, the only open sets are the empty set and the whole space.
  • The Discrete Topology: The collection \(\tau\) contains every possible subset of \(X\). This is the largest possible topology. In this space, every single subset is an open set by definition.
  • The Standard Topology on \(\mathbb{R}\): If \(X\) is the set of all real numbers, we define \(\tau\) as the collection of all open intervals \((a, b)\) and any unions of these intervals. This matches our geometric intuition of open sets while strictly obeying the three axioms.

Why Intersections Must Be Finite

A common question in point-set topology is why unions can be infinite, but intersections must be finite. This rule exists to preserve the behavior of standard geometric spaces, like the real number line.

If infinite intersections of open sets were allowed to be open, you could take the infinite collection of open intervals \((-1/n, 1/n)\) for all positive integers \(n = 1, 2, 3, \dots\). As \(n\) grows to infinity, the intersection of all these intervals shrinks down to a single point: \(\{0\}\). In the standard topology of the real line, a single point is not an open set. Therefore, the axiom restricts intersections to a finite number to prevent open sets from collapsing into non-open points.

Summary

In the axiomatic formulation of point-set topology, an open set has no geometric definition. An open set is strictly defined as an element of a topological space's topology (\(\tau\)), provided that the collection \(\tau\) contains the empty set and the whole space, and remains closed under arbitrary unions and finite intersections.