Category Theory: The Mathematics of Abstract Nonsense

This article explores the fundamentals of category theory, a high-level branch of mathematics that focuses on the relationships between mathematical structures rather than the structures themselves. Furthermore, it explains why mathematicians affectionately refer to this field as "abstract nonsense"—a term that highlights its extreme generality and reliance on structural patterns rather than specific, concrete calculations.

What is Category Theory?

Category theory is often described as the "mathematics of mathematics." Introduced by Samuel Eilenberg and Saunders Mac Lane in the 1940s, it provides a bird’s-eye view of mathematical concepts, allowing practitioners to see shared patterns across entirely different fields, such as algebra, geometry, and logic.

Instead of looking inside a mathematical object to see what it is made of, category theory only cares about how that object interacts with other objects. A "category" consists of just two basic things:

  • Objects: These can be anything, such as sets, numbers, shapes, or data types.
  • Morphisms (or Arrows): These are the relationships, pathways, or functions that connect one object to another.

For a system to be a category, these arrows must follow two simple rules:

  1. Composition: If there is an arrow from Object A to Object B, and another arrow from Object B to Object C, there must be a direct arrow combining them from A to C.
  2. Identity: Every object must have an arrow that loops back to itself, doing nothing to change the object.

By stripping away all the specific details of the objects and focusing purely on the arrows, category theory creates a universal language. If you can prove a rule about how arrows behave in a category, that rule instantly applies to sets, geometric spaces, computer programs, and any other system that fits the categorical structure.

Why is it Called "Abstract Nonsense"?

To an outsider, calling a foundational branch of mathematics "abstract nonsense" sounds like an insult. However, among mathematicians, the phrase is a term of endearment and respect.

The term was popularized in the mid-20th century by mathematician Norman Steenrod, though the founders of the field, Eilenberg and Mac Lane, also used it themselves. There are three main reasons why practitioners use this phrase to describe category theory:

1. Extreme Abstraction

In traditional math, you work with concrete elements. For example, you might add two numbers together or look at the specific points inside a geometric shape. In category theory, you are forbidden from looking "inside" the objects. You do not care what the objects are; you only care about the arrows connecting them. Because the math is entirely divorced from tangible examples, it feels hyper-abstract.

2. Proofs Feel Like "Something for Nothing"

When a mathematician uses category theory to prove a theorem, they often do so without doing any traditional calculations. They don't solve equations or manipulate numbers. Instead, they rely on the sheer logic of how arrows must connect. Because these proofs require no specific data about the objects involved, yet yield powerful truths that apply across all of mathematics, it can feel like a magic trick—or "nonsense."

3. Routine "Diagram Chasing"

Many proofs in category theory are done visually by drawing networks of objects and arrows, known as commutative diagrams. Proving a theorem often involves "diagram chasing," which means tracing your finger along different paths of arrows to show that two different routes lead to the same destination. Once a mathematician sets up the diagram correctly, the proof basically writes itself. Practitioners sometimes call this part of the work "abstract nonsense" because it requires following general, mechanical rules of structure rather than inventing clever, problem-specific tricks.

Ultimately, "abstract nonsense" is a badge of honor. It signifies that a mathematical argument has been elevated to such a high level of pure structure that messy, complicated details are no longer needed to find the truth.