Why Are Fungi More Closely Related to Animals Than Plants?

Fungi and animals share a much closer evolutionary relationship with each other than either group does with plants. Although fungi were historically classified alongside plants due to their stationary lifestyle and presence of cell walls, modern molecular phylogenetics and comparative genomics place fungi and animals together within the eukaryotic supergroup Opisthokonta. Shared structural features, biochemical pathways, and genetic sequences provide overwhelming evidence that animals and fungi diverged from a common ancestor long after their lineage split from the evolutionary branch leading to green plants.

The Opisthokont Clade and Common Ancestry

For decades, taxonomy relied primarily on superficial morphology, grouping fungi with plants because both appear rooted to the ground and develop rigid external structures. However, cladistic analyses of conserved molecular markers—such as ribosomal RNA genes and core metabolic proteins—revolutionized eukaryotic classification.

These studies revealed that eukaryotes are organized into broad supergroups. Plants belong to Archaeplastida, a lineage defined by primary endosymbiosis involving a photosynthetic cyanobacterium. In contrast, animals and fungi share membership in Opisthokonta, a clade unified by distinct evolutionary innovations. The name Opisthokonta derives from the Greek words for "posterior" and "pole," referring to a signature ancestral feature: cells propelled by a single, posterior flagellum, observed in animal sperm cells and primitive chytrid fungal spores.

Key Shared Characteristics Between Animals and Fungi

Beyond phylogenetic sequence alignments, several cellular and biochemical characteristics link fungi to animals rather than plants:

  • Chitin Synthesis: Plants build their rigid cell walls using cellulose. Fungi, however, produce cell walls composed of chitin, a tough polymer of N-acetylglucosamine. Animals also synthesize chitin extensively, utilizing it in the exoskeletons of arthropods, the radulae of mollusks, and the beaks of cephalopods.
  • Heterotrophic Nutrition and Glycogen Storage: Plants are autotrophic organisms capable of generating chemical energy via photosynthesis, storing excess carbohydrates primarily as starch. Both animals and fungi are heterotrophs that must obtain organic carbon from external sources. Additionally, both store surplus energy primarily as glycogen rather than starch.
  • Membrane Sterols and Biosynthesis: While plant cell membranes rely heavily on phytosterols such as stigmasterol and sitosterol, animal and fungal membranes depend on closely related sterols. Fungi synthesize ergosterol and animals produce cholesterol, utilizing shared enzymatic pathways and precursor molecules that distinguish them from plant sterol synthesis.
  • Absence of Chloroplasts: Neither the animal lineage nor the fungal lineage ever possessed photosynthetic plastids derived from the primary endosymbiosis event that defines the plant clade. Fungi digest their food externally by secreting hydrolytic enzymes and absorbing nutrients, mirroring the absorptive heterotrophy seen in ancestral animal relatives.

Molecular Evidence Supporting Opisthokonta

Modern evolutionary biology relies heavily on genome-wide sequencing and multi-gene phylogenies. Comparative analyses of mitochondrial genomes, nuclear genes encoding elongation factors, actin, tubulin, and heat shock proteins consistently place fungi as a sister group to the lineage containing animals and choanoflagellates.

The phylogenetic tree topology reveals that the divergence between Archaeplastida and the lineage leading to Opisthokonta occurred prior to the internal diversification of Opisthokonta itself. Consequently, any genetic or anatomical characteristic shared exclusively between fungi and animals represents either an ancestral opisthokont trait or a derived homologous innovation that green plants never possessed.