How Do Protostomes and Deuterostomes Differ in Development?
In animal biology, bilaterally symmetrical animals are largely categorized into two major evolutionary lineages: protostomes and deuterostomes. These groups are primarily distinguished by fundamental differences established during early embryogenesis. The most significant early developmental divergent traits occur during embryonic cleavage patterns, cell fate determination, the developmental fate of the blastopore, and the specific embryonic mechanisms that direct the formation of the coelom.
Cleavage Patterns and Cell Potency
During the initial mitotic divisions of the zygote, fundamental patterns emerge that define whether an embryo belongs to the protostome or deuterostome branch.
Protostome Cleavage
Protostomes typically undergo spiral cleavage. As cells divide, the planes of cell division are oriented diagonally to the polar axis of the embryo. This causes newly formed smaller cells, known as micromeres, to settle snugly into the grooves between the larger adjacent cells, resulting in an offset, spiral arrangement.
In addition to the spatial arrangement, protostome cleavage is determinate, or mosaic. The developmental fate of each embryonic cell is established very early in division. If an individual cell is removed from a four-cell protostome embryo, that isolated cell lacks the genetic flexibility to form a complete organism; instead, both the remaining embryo and the isolated cell will develop into incomplete, inviable structures missing key tissue types.
Deuterostome Cleavage
Deuterostomes exhibit radial cleavage. In this pattern, the cleavage planes are oriented either parallel or perpendicular to the embryo's polar axis. Consequently, the dividing cells, or blastomeres, are stacked directly on top of one another in aligned tiers rather than shifting into intermediate grooves.
Deuterostome development features indeterminate, or regulative, cleavage. Blastomeres retain cellular pluripotency across several initial divisions. If a blastomere is separated from an early four-cell deuterostome embryo, each cell retains the developmental capacity to regulate its gene expression and develop into a complete, viable organism. This property of indeterminate cleavage enables the phenomenon of identical twinning in deuterostomes such as vertebrates.
Fate of the Blastopore
Gastrulation marks the migration and inward folding of cells to establish the primary germ layers (ectoderm, endoderm, and mesoderm) and forms an internal cavity known as the archenteron (primitive gut). The opening of this cavity to the exterior is called the blastopore.
In protostomes, whose name translates from Greek to mean "first mouth," the blastopore typically develops into the organism's mouth. If a secondary opening forms later on the opposite end of the digestive tract, it develops into the anus.
In deuterostomes, meaning "second mouth," the blastopore develops into the anus. The secondary opening that forms subsequently at the opposite end of the developing digestive tract becomes the mouth.
Mechanisms of Coelom Formation
The coelom is the primary body cavity located between the digestive tract and the outer body wall, completely lined with mesodermal tissue. The embryonic origin of this mesoderm and the mechanism used to create the fluid-filled cavity differ fundamentally between the two groups.
Schizocoely in Protostomes
Protostomes typically form their coelom via schizocoely. During gastrulation, solid blocks of mesodermal cells differentiate near the base of the blastopore and migrate into the space between the endoderm and ectoderm. As development progresses, these solid masses of mesoderm split internally down the center. The resulting hollow spaces expand within the mesodermal tissue to form the coelomic cavity.
Enterocoely in Deuterostomes
Deuterostomes typically form their coelom via enterocoely. Rather than migrating as independent solid masses, mesodermal tissue buds directly from the lateral walls of the archenteron. These outpocketings form hollow mesodermal pouches that gradually pinch off from the gut wall. Once completely separated from the archenteron, the cavities inside these expanding mesodermal pouches enlarge and coalesce to constitute the functional coelom.
Summary of Major Developmental Differences
Protostomes
- Cleavage geometry: Spiral cleavage
- Blastomere developmental fate: Determinate (mosaic)
- Blastopore fate: Develops into the mouth
- Coelom origin: Schizocoely (splitting of solid mesodermal masses)
- Representative phyla: Mollusca, Annelida, Arthropoda
Deuterostomes
- Cleavage geometry: Radial cleavage
- Blastomere developmental fate: Indeterminate (regulative)
- Blastopore fate: Develops into the anus
- Coelom origin: Enterocoely (outpocketing of archenteron walls)
- Representative phyla: Echinodermata, Hemichordata, Chordata