How Cadherins Sort Tissues in Embryos?
During embryonic morphogenesis, developing tissues segregate and organize into distinct functional layers through a biophysical sorting process largely orchestrated by cadherin proteins. Cells with differing types or levels of cadherins establish differences in intercellular adhesive strength and cortical tension. Much like immiscible liquids separating by surface tension, heterogeneous cell populations self-assemble into coherent, boundaries-defined compartments. This phenomenon explains fundamental developmental events such as neural tube segregation, germ layer positioning, and somite boundary formation.
The Differential Adhesion Hypothesis
The physical foundation of cell sorting was formulated by Malcolm Steinberg in the 1960s as the Differential Adhesion Hypothesis (DAH). Steinberg proposed that cell populations behave mechanically like immiscible liquids. Just as oil and water demix to minimize the system's total free energy, mixed cell aggregates rearrange to maximize adhesive binding energy.
In thermodynamic terms, the system minimizes its interfacial free energy:
\[\Delta G = \sum \gamma_{ij} A_{ij}\]
where \(\gamma_{ij}\) represents the interfacial tension between cell types \(i\) and \(j\), and \(A_{ij}\) is the contact area between them. When two cell populations are mixed:
- If cohesive forces within one cell population exceed the adhesive forces between differing populations (\(\gamma_{inter} > \gamma_{intra}\)), the cells will separate into distinct compartments.
- The population possessing higher cohesive affinity (greater self-adhesion) will become internally engulfed by the population with lower cohesive affinity, forming a sphere surrounded by an external layer.
The Cadherin Superfamily and Adhesion Mechanics
Cadherins are calcium-dependent transmembrane glycoproteins that mediate cell-cell adhesion at adherens junctions. The classical cadherins—such as E-cadherin (epithelial), N-cadherin (neural), and P-cadherin (placental)—contain an extracellular domain composed of five cadherin repeats (EC1 to EC5).
The molecular mechanism of cadherin-mediated sorting relies on two principal variables:
Quantitative Differences
Cells expressing identical types of cadherins can sort purely based on expression density. Cells engineered to express high levels of E-cadherin internally segregate from cells expressing low levels of E-cadherin. The high-expression cells generate a greater total adhesive bond density, yielding higher aggregate surface tension and adopting the internal position in mixed aggregates.
Qualitative Differences
Distinct cadherin subtypes preferentially engage in homophilic interactions (binding to the same cadherin subtype on neighboring cells) over heterophilic interactions. For instance, the trans-dimerization affinity between two N-cadherin molecules or two E-cadherin molecules is significantly higher than that between an E-cadherin and an N-cadherin molecule. Consequently, cells sorting across subtype boundaries minimize unfavorable heterophilic contacts to form sharp physical interfaces.
Interplay Between Adhesion and Cortical Tension
While Steinberg's DAH focused strictly on passive adhesion energy, modern developmental biology integrates active actomyosin contractility through the Differential Interfacial Tension Hypothesis (DITH). Interfacial tension \(\gamma\) is a net balance between cadherin adhesion (\(W_{adh}\)), which expands cell-cell contacts, and the cortical tension generated by the actomyosin cortex (\(T_{cortical}\)), which acts to round cells up:
\[\gamma = 2(T_{cortical} - W_{adh})\]
Cadherins do not function merely as passive glue; their cytoplasmic domains interact with p120-catenin and \(\beta\)-catenin, which bind \(\alpha\)-catenin. The \(\alpha\)-catenin protein links the adhesion complex dynamically to the filamentous actin (F-actin) cytoskeleton and recruits non-muscle myosin II motors. Differences in local cortical contraction combined with homophilic cadherin binding determine the final equilibrium geometry of sorting tissues.
Tissue Boundary Formation and Morphogenetic Events
Cadherin-dependent sorting operates across several major morphogenetic milestones:
- Neural Tube Closure: Initially, the prospective neural plate and epidermal ectoderm both express E-cadherin. As neurulation proceeds, neural plate cells downregulate E-cadherin and upregulate N-cadherin. This switch drives the invagination and complete physical segregation of the neural tube from the overlying surface ectoderm.
- Germ Layer Separation: During gastrulation in vertebrates, differential expression and activity of E-cadherin, N-cadherin, and protocadherins facilitate the clean separation of endoderm, mesoderm, and ectoderm layers.
- Eph-Ephrin Cross-talk: Tissue sorting often involves reciprocal signaling pathways such as Eph receptors and ephrin ligands, which locally downregulate cadherin clustering or elevate actomyosin contractility at contact boundaries to prevent cell intermingling.